Related Experiment Videos
Disability, connectivity and transgressing the autonomous body.
1Department of Physical Therapy, University of Toronto, 500 University Avenue, 8th Floor, Toronto, ON, M5G 1V7, Canada. barbara.gibson@utoronto.ca
The Journal of Medical Humanities
|July 22, 2006
Summary
This study critiques Western ideals of independence, showing how disability connectivities with technology and others reveal a more fluid, interconnected subjectivity. It suggests a new ethics beyond individual rights for understanding disability.
Area of Science:
- Disability Studies
- Philosophy
- Science and Technology Studies
Background:
- Western philosophical traditions often emphasize the independent, autonomous subject.
- These notions of independence can marginalize individuals with disabilities by framing their needs as deficiencies.
- Discourses valorizing self-sufficiency can inadvertently contribute to the social exclusion of disabled bodies.
Purpose of the Study:
- To challenge the dominant Western concept of the independent subject in relation to disability.
- To explore the interconnectedness of disabled individuals, technologies, and the environment.
- To propose an expanded understanding of subjectivity and ethics based on interdependence.
Main Methods:
- Critiquing prevailing discourses on independence using Deleuze and Guattari's philosophy of 'becoming'.
- Analyzing three case studies of disability connectivities: human-dog, human-machine, and woman-woman relationships.
- Examining how these connectivities illustrate partial and transitory forms of subjectivity.
Main Results:
- Subjectivity is demonstrated to be partial, fluid, and context-dependent, rather than static and independent.
- Disability 'dependencies' are reframed as vital connectivities that constitute subjectivity.
- The concept of 'disability connectivity' highlights the relational nature of being.
Conclusions:
- The independent subject model is inadequate for understanding disability and human experience.
- Disability connectivities offer a pathway to a more inclusive and accurate understanding of subjectivity.
- An ethics premised on interdependence, rather than individual rights, is necessary for social justice.