Unusual origins of isotope effects in enzyme-catalysed reactions

High hydrostatic pressure is a neglected tool for probing the origins of isotope effects. In chemical reactions, normal primary deuterium isotope effects (DIEs) arising solely from differences in zero point energies are unaffected by pressure; but some anomalous isotope effects in which hydrogen tunnelling is suspected are partially suppressed. In some enzymatic reactions, high pressure completely suppresses the DIE. We have now measured the effects of high pressure on the parallel 13C heavy atom isotope effect of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase and found that it is also suppressed by high pressure and, similarly, suppressed in its entirety. Moreover, the volume changes associated with the suppression of both deuterium and heavy atom isotope effects are virtually identical. The equivalent decrease in activation volumes for hydride transfer, when one mass unit is added to the carbon end of a scissile C-H bond as when one mass unit is added to the hydrogen end, suggests a common origin. Given that carbon is highly unlikely to undergo tunnelling, it follows that hydrogen is not doing so either. The origin of these isotope effects must lie elsewhere. We offer protein domain motions as a possibility.