Multiple extrema in the intermolecular potential and the phase diagram of protein solutions

Recent experiments have revealed several surprising features of the phase equilibria in protein solutions: liquid-liquid phase separation which is, in some cases, metastable with respect to the liquid-solid equilibrium, and in others-unobservable; widely varying crystallization enthalpies, including completely athermal crystallization; the co-existence of several crystalline polymorphs; and others. Other studies have shown that the solvent molecules at the hydrophobic and polar patches on the protein molecular surfaces are structured, introducing repulsive forces at surface separations equal to several water molecule sizes. In search of a causal link between the latter and former findings, we apply Monte Carlo simulation techniques in the investigation of phase diagrams associated with globular biological molecules in solution. We account for the solvent structuring via short-range isotropic two-body intermolecular potentials exhibiting multiple extrema. We show that the introduction of a repulsive maximum or a secondary attractive minimum at separations longer than the primary attractive minimum has dramatic effects on the phase diagram: liquid-liquid separation curves are driven to lower or higher temperatures, the sensitivity of the solubility curve (liquidus) to temperature, i.e., the enthalpy of crystallization, is significantly reduced or enhanced, metastable liquid-liquid separation may become stable and vice versa, and both low- and high-density crystalline phases are observed. The similarity of these features of the simulated phase behavior to those observed experimentally suggests that at least some of the mysteries of the protein phase equilibria may be due to the structuring of the solvent around the protein molecular surfaces. Another conclusion is that at least some of the dense liquids seen in protein solutions may be stable and not metastable with respect to a solid phase.