Permanganate oxidation of alkenes. Substituent and solvent effects. Difficulties with MP2 calculations

The permanganate oxidation of alkenes has been studied both experimentally and computationally. Transition state structures were located for the reaction of permanganate ion with a variety of monosubstituted alkenes at the B3LYP/6-311++G** level. Although the calculated activation energy for the reaction with ethene was reasonable, the calculated effect of substituents, based on the energies of the reactants, was much larger than that experimentally found. This was shown to be due to the formation of an intermediate charge-dipole complex which led to the transition state. Reaction field calculations found the complex to disappear in a high dielectric constant medium, and the range of activation energies for the reaction in solution became quite small. MP2 calculations were carried out in order to have a comparison with the DFT results. MP2-MP4 gave unusual results for calculations on permanganate ion as well as chromate ion and iron tetraoxide. They also gave markedly unreasonable results for the activation energy of the reaction of permanganate with ethane. CCSD/6-311++G** calculations gave satisfactory results for permanganate ion and chromate ion. At this level of theory, the reaction of permanganate with ethene was found to have a very early transition state, when the bond lengths of the reactants just began to change. The reaction was calculated to be very exothermic (-69 kcal/mol), and this was confirmed via calorimetry. The rates of permanganate oxidation of allyl alcohol and acrylonitrile were determined, and they had similar reactivities. The kinetics and the products of the reaction of permanganate with crotonate ion were examined in some detail.