Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 19, 2026

A Clinical Trial Assessing the Safety, Efficacy, and Delivery of Olive-Oil-Based Three-Chamber Bags for Parenteral Nutrition
Published on: September 20, 2019
Randomized trial for answers to clinical questions: evaluating a pre-appraised versus a MEDLINE search protocol
Manesh R Patel1, Connie M Schardt, Linda L Sanders
1Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina, USA. manesh.patel@duke.edu
Objective:
The paper compares the speed, validity, and applicability of two different protocols for searching the primary medical literature.
Design:
A randomized trial involving medicine residents was performed.
Setting:
An inpatient general medicine rotation was used.
Participants:
Thirty-two internal medicine residents were block randomized into four groups of eight.
Main Outcome Measures:
Success rate of each search protocol was measured by perceived search time, number of questions answered, and proportion of articles that were applicable and valid.
Results:
Residents randomized to the MEDLINE-first (protocol A) group searched 120 questions, and residents randomized to the MEDLINE-last (protocol B) searched 133 questions. In protocol A, 104 answers (86.7%) and, in protocol B, 117 answers (88%) were found to clinical questions. In protocol A, residents reported that 26 (25.2%) of the answers were obtained quickly or rated as "fast" (<5 minutes) as opposed to 55 (51.9%) in protocol B, (P = 0.0004). A subset of questions and articles (n = 79) were reviewed by faculty who found that both protocols identified similar numbers of answer articles that addressed the questions and were felt to be valid using critical appraisal criteria.
Conclusion:
For resident-generated clinical questions, both protocols produced a similarly high percentage of applicable and valid articles. The MEDLINE-last search protocol was perceived to be faster. However, in the MEDLINE-last protocol, a significant portion of questions (23%) still required searching MEDLINE to find an answer.
Related Concept Videos
Clinical Trials
There are four phases in a clinical trial. A phase one...
Clinical Trials: Overview
Types of Biopharmaceutical Studies: Controlled and Non-Controlled Approaches
Non-controlled studies, commonly employed for initial exploration, lack a control group, rendering them susceptible to biases and external influences. In contrast, controlled...
Blind Procedures
Preclinical Development: Overview
Randomized Experiments
Simple randomization
Simple...
