Comparison between phytoestrogens and estradiol in the prevention of atheroma in ovariectomized cholesterol-fed...

There is increasing interest in the role of complementary and alternative medicines for the treatment of menopause-related problems. This study compared the preventive effect on atheroma formation of a commercially available mixed phytoestrogen concentrate with that of estradiol.

An ovariectomized cholesterol-fed rabbit model of atheroma formation was used. Rabbits were ovariectomized before the commencement of the 12-week treatment period. There were two control groups. Control Group 1 received isoflavone-free rabbit chow whilst Control Group 2 received 1% cholesterol-enriched isoflavone-free rabbit chow. Rabbits in Group 3 received 1% cholesterol-enriched isoflavone-free rabbit chow plus a 500 mg tablet containing a concentrated extract of Trifolium pretense (red clover). Rabbits in Group 4 received 1% cholesterol-enriched isoflavone-free rabbit chow plus a 0.5 mg tablet of oral estradiol. Atheroma formation was measured by, first, calculation of the area of atheroma on the intimal surface, and, second, measuring the cholesterol content in the aorta.

There were no significant differences in serum cholesterol between the cholesterol-fed control Group 2 and the treatment Groups 3 and 4. However, there was significantly less staining for atheroma and significantly less cholesterol accumulation in the aorta in Group 4 (estradiol-treated) rabbits compared with either control Group 2 or Group 3 (phytoestrogen-treated) rabbits.

In this study, only estradiol was shown to have a significant protective effect against atheroma formation.