Reliability and usefulness of a new in vivo measurement system of the pivot shift

Residual pivot shift after ACL reconstruction is a crucial factor related to poor clinical outcome. However, no method exists that is able to evaluate pivot shift quantitatively and noninvasively. We propose a new measurement system for the pivot shift test using an electromagnetic device and have evaluated its reliability and clinical usefulness. Posterior translation, lateral translation and maximum velocity during the reduction phase of pivot shift were calculated and used as parameters for evaluation. In measurement system analysis, discrepancies of motion between the bones and the sensors were minimal, while reproducibility in repeated measurement was acceptable. Next, clinical usefulness was evaluated by correlating the values obtained by kinematic measurement with the clinical grade. We found differences in each of the measured parameters among clinical grades. These data suggest the system is a valuable measurement tool for clinical evaluation of the pivot shift test.