Long-term comparative outcomes between 2 common ureteroneocystostomy techniques for renal transplantation

We compared the incidence of ureteral complications between the classic (Lich-Gregoir) technique and the recently popularized single stitch (Shanfield) technique in renal transplantation.

The charts of 721 consecutive transplant recipients from May 1999 to July 2002 were retrospectively reviewed. Ureteral and nonureteral complications were reviewed at 3 to 5-year followup.

Of the 721 recipients evaluated 713 were included in the study. There were 360 recipients in the Lich-Gregoir group and 353 in the Shanfield group. A significantly higher rate of ureteral complications occurred in the Shanfield group compared to the Lich-Gregoir group (15.6% vs 3.9%, p <0.0001). The Shanfield group consisted of 20 patients with ureteral leakage, 21 with hematuria, 11 with strictures and 3 who had ureteral stones. The Lich-Gregoir group had 8 patients with ureteral leakage, 5 with hematuria and 1 with a stricture. In comparison, urinary tract infections, delayed graft function and rejection rates were not significantly different between the 2 groups (p = 0.76, 0.12 and 0.19, respectively).

In contrast to other reports, the Shanfield group had significantly more ureteral complications. In particular the Shanfield technique may predispose patients to higher rates of hematuria and stone formation. Based on this large series and published meta-analyses we believe that the stented Lich-Gregoir anastomosis is the superior ureteroneocystostomy technique in renal transplantation.