A note on the use of outlier criteria in Ontario laboratory quality control schemes
Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 17, 2026

Microbial Control and Monitoring Strategies for Cleanroom Environments and Cellular Therapies
Published on: March 17, 2023
Kevin Hayes1, Anthony Kinsella, Norma Coffey
1Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Limerick, Limerick, Republic of Ireland. Kevin.Hayes@ul.ie
Objectives:
This paper examines the pitfalls that arise when an outlier is assessed using a criterion based on a fixed multiple of the standard deviation rather than an established statistical test. Although the former approach is statistically invalid, it is the favored method for identifying outliers in Ontario laboratory quality control protocols.
Design And Methods:
Computer simulations are used to calculate the probability of a false positive result (classifying a valid observation as an outlier) when outlier criteria based on fixed multiples of the standard deviation are applied to samples containing no outliers.
Results:
The estimated probability of a false positive result is tabulated over various sample sizes. Outlier criteria based on fixed multiples of the standard deviation are shown to be highly inefficient.
Conclusions:
This work presents arguments for discontinuing the widespread practice of using outlier criteria based on fixed multiples of the standard deviation to identify outliers in univariate samples.
Related Concept Videos
Detection of Gross Error: The Q Test
Quantifying and Rejecting Outliers: The Grubbs Test
What Are Outliers?
The z score is used to find outliers or unusual values. It should be noted that any values beyond -2 and +2 are...
Outliers and Influential Points
Data Validation
Key parameters for method validation include:
Modified Boxplots
However, the box plot does not tell the reader about outliers - values that lie far from the center of the data. We can modify the standard box and whisker plot to identify the outliers and visualize the actual spread of the data in a sample.
Initially, we calculate the adjusted...

