Esterase genes in parallel composite cross barley populations

The California population of Composite Cross V of barley was used as the source of three subpopulations that were started from generations 10, 20 and 30, respectively, and were grown in parallel environmental conditions in Cambridge for eight generations. Outcrossing rates (0.2%) were even lower than in the California material, and heterozygotes were correspondingly rare, so that the populations were essentially mixtures of homozygous lines. Four esterase loci that were polymorphic in the base Composite Cross V remained so in all the derived populations, but showed considerable changes in allelic frequency over time, particularly at two of the genes. Multilocus analysis showed that strong directional changes occurred in all three populations, but they were not consistent. One particular genotype became predominant in the population derived from generation 10, whereas in the other two populations it was a genotype with different alleles at the Est1 and Est3 loci that rose to frequencies of more than 50%. Strong directional selection undoubtedly occurred in these populations, but did not cause parallel changes in esterase gene frequencies. These data do not facilitate a discrimination between the alternative explanations of hitchhiking or multilocus selection at these loci.