New grading system for patients with treacher Collins syndrome

Treacher Collins syndrome (TCS) is a congenital, craniofacial disorder affecting the development of structures derived from the first and second branchial arches. The associated clinical features and their severity are variable. Therefore, we reasoned that objective assessment of the clinical features and their severity in TCS is necessary to plan the treatment and to evaluate the outcome. We hereby propose a new grading system for Treacher Collins syndrome (TCS). Since 1978, 16 patients have been diagnosed with TCS. Eleven out of the 16 TCS patients, for whom we were able to estimate the severity of the clinical features in each region, and to make an objective assessment of the therapeutic outcomes, were selected. By allocating points according to the degree of severity of the clinical features in each region, then summing them up and categorizing them, we classified the overall clinical features into 3 grades. The severity increases from grades I to III. In summary, there were 3 patients of grade I, 4 patients of grade II and 4 patients of grade III. Distinctive differences regarding the degree of severity of the clinical features were clearly observed between each grade. We propose a new TCS grading system and applied it to 11 patients. We believe that this system may be useful for planning treatment and to evaluate the outcome in TCS patients.