Alternative confirmatory strategies in HIV-1 antibody testing

Alternatives to confirmation of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-1 seropositivity by Western blot analysis were evaluated retrospectively using combinations of six anti-HIV-1 screening assays, including four enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) and two simple tests (a rapid dot immunoassay and an agglutination assay), according to an algorithm where sera are first screened by one assay and those repeatedly reactive on this assay are tested repeatedly by a second assay. Two panels of sera collected in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, were used. Panel 1 was composed of 1,465 consecutive blood donor sera of which 99 (6.8%) were confirmed HIV-1 antibody positive, and panel 2 was composed of sera from 396 consecutively admitted patients at two medical wards of which 116 (29.3%) were confirmed HIV-1 antibody positive. Sera reactive on any of the six screening assays were also tested by a confirmatory Western blot assay. The sensitivity of the assays at the initial valid testing were as follows: Abbott 99.5%, Behring 99.5%, Organon 97.7%, Wellcozyme 100%, HIV CHEK-1 95.8%, and Serodia 95.8%. After repeat testing of sera that initially gave false-negative results all assays showed 100% sensitivity except HIV CHEK-1 (98.6%). The specificities after repeat testing were between 99.6 and 99.9% for all assays except for the Behring ELISA (98.1%). Several combinations of screening assays were found to give the same diagnostic accuracy as the screening assay followed by Western blot analysis. We conclude that an alternative confirmatory strategy can be fully satisfactory for some testing purposes.