Evaluation of the float sign for determining adequacy of specimens obtained with transbronchial biopsy

This study prospectively evaluated the alveolar content of transbronchial biopsy specimens based on whether or not they floated in formalin. One hundred biopsy specimens were obtained from 18 patients. Specimens with any alveoli were significantly more likely to float (45 of 61, 74%) than those with no alveolar tissue (15 of 39, 39%; p less than 0.001). The majority of diagnostic specimens were obtained in eight patients with sarcoidosis, where 47 biopsies were obtained. Fourteen of 19 specimens (74%) with noncaseating granulomas floated, whereas only 11 of 28 (39%; p less than 0.05) nondiagnostic specimens floated. The results of this study suggest that this simple bedside observation may serve to determine the adequacy of transbronchial biopsy specimens, particularly in sarcoidosis.