Graded stress radiography of injured anterior cruciate ligaments

Fifty-five patients with clinical suspicion of injury to their anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) were examined by graded stress radiography before arthroscopic verification in an effort to determine the loss of ACL function as a result of ligament tearing. Using a commercially available stress device capable of applying varying pressures to the mid-calf, anterior drawers were measured from lateral radiographs at 0-, 7-, 14-, and 21-kiloPascal pressures and used to calculate the equivalent elastic modulus of the remaining ACL fibers. According to viscoelastic theory, this modulus is proportional to the number of elastically active fibers in the ligament. To verify the validity of this concept, the stress-strain relationship of a freshly excised ACL ligament was examined in a tensile testing machine, and the procedure was repeated after the ligament had been partially transsected with a scalpel. Comparison with the elastic modulus of the (intact) ACL of the opposite knee permits an estimate of the percentage of rupture in cases of partial tears. Overstretched ligaments show essentially normal viscoelastic properties once the slack in the ligament has been taken up. Complete tears, on the other hand, show a complete breakdown in the viscoelastic properties of the ACL. The results show that partial tears can be diagnosed by graded stress radiography with a sensitivity of 20% and specificity of 90%. Diagnosis of overstretched ligaments had sensitivity of 50% and specificity of 94%. Complete tears were detected with sensitivity of 88% and specificity of 75% as diagnosed against all other ACL lesions and including normals.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)