Biomechanical comparison of cannulated small bone screws: a brief follow-up study

The compressive forces generated by the ASIF and Herbert small bone cannulated screws were measured in the laboratory with the use of simulated bones and a custom-designed load washer as a means of quantifying their fixation capabilities. Comparative data were also generated for the Herbert scaphoid bone screw and the ASIF 4 mm cancellous screw. The cannulated Herbert bone screw and the ASIF 4 mm cancellous screw were found to have nearly identical compression capabilities. Both generated compression forces approximately five times those of the Herbert scaphoid bone screw. The ASIF small cannulated screw demonstrated a compressive capacity 2 1/2 times that of the Herbert screw.