Evaluation of immune regulation in transplant patients using the trans vivo delayed type hypersensitivity assay

Allograft recipient IL-10 and/or transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) dependent anti-inflammatory T-cell delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses to donor derived antigens, or regulatory T-cell responses, have been demonstrated in rodents and transplant patients using a previously described trans vivo DTH assay. We used this assay to determine the incidence of recipient anti-inflammatory T-cell responses to donor antigens in a large cohort (n = 420) of primary kidney and simultaneous kidney-pancreas transplant patients tested a mean of 4.8 years after transplantation. The results were compared with clinical outcomes and the presence of detectable circulating alloantibodies. We found an unexpectedly high incidence (21.9%) of this anti-inflammatory T-cell response to donor antigens in these recipients. There was a significant correlation between this T-cell phenotype and the presence of detectable circulating alloantibodies (p = 0.03). There was no correlation between this T-cell phenotype and the degree of HLA mismatch. In addition, the presence of an anti-inflammatory DTH response to donor antigens did not correlate with an improved clinical outcome at a median of nearly 5 years after transplantation. These findings suggest that detection of an anti-inflammatory T-cell response to donor antigens does not identify patients that have developed graft protective, regulatory T-cell responses.