Do men and women use the same criteria in selecting a general surgery residency program? Results of a 20-year study...

To assess applicant preferences in general surgery program selection, we surveyed current and former residents of our non-university general surgery residency program over the last 20 years, with particular emphasis on male and female selection preferences.

Surveys were distributed to current and former categorical residents. Respondents were asked to rate 25 residency criteria using a Likert scale. Responses by males and females were compared using the Mann-Whitney U-test. Results are reported as mean scores, with p-values indicating statistical significance of trends toward higher scores.

Of 50 former (76% male, 24% female) and 18 current residents (56% male, 44% female), 56 responded (38 male, 18 female), for an overall response rate of 82%. For both male and female respondents, the top 4 selection criteria by mean average score were identical: variety and number of cases, friendly training environment, camaraderie among residents, and quality of relationships with attendings. Selection criteria that received significantly higher scores among women were camaraderie among residents, the number of female residents, and the number of female attendings (p < 0.05). For men, a suburban location, compensation and benefits, and the reputation of the program director received significantly higher scores (p < 0.05). Gender-related selection preference was most marked for the number of female residents (mean, 2.4 for women vs 1.3 for men) and the number of female attendings (mean, 2.3 for women vs 1.4 for men). These 2 criteria, however, were ranked 20th and 21st (of the 25), respectively, by the female respondents.

The most important selection criteria, regardless of gender, relate to operative experience, training environment, and quality relationships. Gender-based preferences seem to play only a minor role in general surgery program selection.