Why modest geographic effects for asthma? Pharmaceutical treatment as neutralizing mechanism

Research on geographic health effects has been greatly advanced with the development of multilevel statistical techniques but less is known about the possible mechanisms by which social and geographical environments may affect physical health. In spite of well-established relationships between asthma etiology and the broader living environments, multilevel research on asthma shows at best marginal geographic effects. Based on in-depth, open-ended interviews with 50 caretakers of school-age children (6-12 years) diagnosed with asthma living in two different communities, this article elucidates mechanisms by which neighborhood effects may be neutralized. Caretakers of children with mild, controllable asthma attempt to create asthma-safe zones by administering long-term control and quick-relief medication, by removing indoor environmental triggers and by avoiding dangerous environments. At home, school and outdoors, the key strategy to control asthma was the use of relatively effective and accessible medications. Children with severe asthma did not benefit as much from medications but it was unclear that different communities made a difference in asthma care.