Related Experiment Videos
The development of distributive justice orientations: contextual influences on children's resource allocations
1Department of Psychology, University of Arizona, Tucson 85721.
Insights
Children’s understanding of fairness develops with age. Young children prefer equal distribution, while older children adapt their justice decisions based on the specific situation, showing a contextual understanding of fairness.
Area of Science:
- Developmental Psychology
- Social Psychology
- Moral Development
Background:
- Previous research on distributive justice primarily focused on reward allocation for work productivity.
- Limited understanding exists regarding children's ability to select contextually appropriate justice norms.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the development of children's ability to select justice norms (equity, equality, need) appropriate to specific situations.
- To examine how contextual factors influence children's distributive justice decisions.
Main Methods:
- Children aged 5, 9, and 13 were presented with scenarios requiring resource allocation.
- Participants judged the fairness of different decision rules (equity, equality, need) in context-specific situations.
Main Results:
- Younger children (5-year-olds) showed insensitivity to context, generally preferring equal resource distribution.
- Older children (9 and 13-year-olds) demonstrated context-sensitive decision-making, applying appropriate justice norms.
- Developmental trends in norm selection varied across different situational contexts.
Conclusions:
- Children's development of distributive justice is context-dependent, not a uniform progression.
- A contextual perspective is crucial for understanding the nuances of developing fairness orientations in children.
Abstract:
Previous research on the development of distributive justice decisions, by centering largely on situations in which rewards for work productivity are to be allocated, has shed little light on the child's developing ability to select the justice norm most appropriate to the situation. Children 5, 9, and 13 years of age were asked to allocate resources and judge the fairness of alternative decision rules in situations to which either equity, equality, or need norms were especially applicable. As predicted, young children were insensitive to contextual information, generally preferring to allocate resources equally, whereas older children tailored their decisions appropriately to the situation. The fact that developmental trends differed from situation to situation points to the importance of adopting a contextual perspective on the development of distributive justice orientations.