Toward a general synthesis of chlorins

Recently, we described a new synthesis of C,D-ring symmetric chlorins 11, involving 2 + 2 condensation of bis-formyl-dihydrodipyrrins 9 with symmetrically substituted dipyrromethane diacids 10 (Method I). However, while versatile in many aspects, Method I was unsuited to the broader goal of synthesizing fully non-symmetric chlorins of general structure 15, which requires regioselective control over the reacting centers in the A,B- and C,D-ring components. In this paper, we describe four new 2 + 2 strategies that accomplish this differentiation (Methods II-V). Of these, Method V, which combines operational simplicity with moderate to high product yields, proved to be the most effective route, exploiting reactivity differences between the two formyl groups of A,B-rings 9 to impart excellent regioselectivity. Methods II-IV are also useful alternatives to Method V, although in some cases, the appropriately functionalized precursors are less readily available. All four approaches generate single regioisomers of diversely substituted chlorins, and in every case, the 2 + 2 condensation is accomplished in a simple, one-flask procedure without need for additives such as oxidizing agents or metals. Taken together, these methodologies provide expanded access to an array of chlorins for SAR studies that may advance the effectiveness of PDT and other applications.