Max-product algorithms for the generalized multiple-fault diagnosis problem
Tung Le1, Christoforos N Hadjicostis
1Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Coordinated Science Laboratory, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL 61801, USA. tungle1@uiuc.edu
Abstract:
In this paper, we study the application of the max-product algorithm (MPA) to the generalized multiple-fault diagnosis (GMFD) problem, which consists of components (to be diagnosed) and alarms/connections that can be unreliable. The MPA and the improved sequential MPA (SMPA) that we develop in this paper are local-message-passing algorithms that operate on the bipartite diagnosis graph (BDG) associated with the GMFD problem and converge to the maximum a posteriori probability (MAP) solution if this graph is acyclic (in addition, the MPA requires the MAP solution to be unique). Our simulations suggest that both the MPA and the SMPA perform well in more general systems that may exhibit cycles in the associated BDGs (the SMPA also appears to outperform the MPA in these more general systems). In this paper, we provide analytical results for acyclic BDGs and also assess the performance of both algorithms under particular patterns of alarm observations in general graphs; this allows us to obtain analytical bounds on the probability of making erroneous diagnosis with respect to the MAP solution. We also evaluate the performance of the MPA and the SMPA algorithms via simulations, and provide comparisons with previously developed heuristics for this type of diagnosis problems. We conclude that the MPA and the SMPA perform well under reasonable computational complexity when the underlying diagnosis graph is sparse.
Insights
The max-product algorithm (MPA) and sequential MPA (SMPA) effectively diagnose generalized multiple faults, especially in sparse systems. SMPA shows improved performance in complex systems with cycles.
Area of Science:
- Computer Science
- Electrical Engineering
- Systems Engineering
Background:
- The generalized multiple-fault diagnosis (GMFD) problem involves identifying faults in systems with unreliable components and alarms.
- Existing diagnostic methods face challenges in complex systems with interconnected components and potential cycles.
Purpose of the Study:
- To apply and evaluate the max-product algorithm (MPA) and a novel sequential MPA (SMPA) for GMFD.
- To analyze algorithm performance on bipartite diagnosis graphs (BDGs), including acyclic and cyclic cases.
Main Methods:
- Developed and applied MPA and SMPA, which are local message-passing algorithms.
- Utilized bipartite diagnosis graphs (BDGs) to model the GMFD problem.
- Conducted simulations and analytical assessments for various graph structures and alarm patterns.
Main Results:
- MPA and SMPA converge to the maximum a posteriori probability (MAP) solution for acyclic BDGs.
- Simulations indicate strong performance for both MPA and SMPA in general systems, with SMPA outperforming MPA in systems with cycles.
- Analytical bounds on erroneous diagnosis probability were derived for general graphs.
Conclusions:
- MPA and SMPA offer efficient solutions for GMFD with reasonable computational complexity, particularly for sparse diagnosis graphs.
- SMPA demonstrates enhanced performance over MPA in more complex, cyclic system models.
- The algorithms provide a robust approach to fault diagnosis in unreliable systems.
Related Concept Videos
Multimachine Stability
In analyzing the system, the nodal equations represent the relationship between bus voltages, machine voltages, and machine currents. The nodal equation is given by:
Bus Impedance Matrix
In the first circuit, all machine voltage sources are short-circuited, leaving only the prefault voltage source at the fault location. The positive-sequence bus impedance matrix can be determined by solving the nodal equations,...
Mechanistic Models: Compartment Models in Algorithms for Numerical Problem Solving
In individual population analyses, different algorithms are employed, such as Cauchy's method, which uses a...
Fault Types
For line-to-line faults occurring between phases B and C, the...
Gaussian Elimination: Problem Solving
Methods of Medium Optimization
