Comparison of lesion sizes produced by cryoablation and open irrigation radiofrequency ablation catheters

The relative lesion sizes created by large electrode cryoablation catheter and irrigated radiofrequency (RF) ablation are not known. The purpose of this study was to directly compare lesion sizes created by cryoablation and irrigated RF under controlled conditions.

Ablation lesions were created in freshly harvested porcine left ventricular myocardium in a blood-filled tissue bath using an 8-mm-tip cryoablation catheter and a 3.5-mm-tip open-irrigated RF ablation catheter. Lesions were created under all permutations of the following conditions: electrode orientation vertical (perpendicular) or horizontal (parallel) to the tissue, electrode contact pressure at 6 or 20 g, and blood flow at 0.2 or 0.4 m/s over the electrode-tissue interface. The largest lesion volumes created with cryoablation were 961 +/- 103 mm(3), compared with the largest lesions volumes created with RF of 680 +/- 48 mm(3) (P < 0.001). The 3-way interactions among electrode orientation, contact pressure, and superfusate blood velocity accounted for the variation in lesion volumes for both catheters (both r(2)= 0.97, both P < 0.0001). The greater contact pressure increased lesion size for both cryoablation and RF. For cryoablation, lesion sizes were increased by the horizontal orientation and by the lower blood flow velocity. For open-irrigated RF, lesion sizes were significantly reduced by the horizontal orientation, however.

Depending on conditions of electrode orientation, contact pressure, and blood velocity, either 8-mm-tip cryoablation or open-irrigated RF may produce the larger lesion volumes. Open-irrigated RF lesion sizes are reduced in the horizontal catheter orientation.