Surgical treatment of traumatic peroneal nerve lesions

In this study, we compare different surgical procedures regarding the functional outcome of traumatic peroneal nerve lesions.

In a retrospective study, 48 patients with traumatic lesions (17 iatrogenic) of the peroneal nerve were evaluated. Twenty-two patients presented with lesions in continuity displaying regenerative potential by nerve action potential recording. In these cases, surgery was restricted to either external (12/) or interfascicular neurolysis (10/). Twenty-two cases had no regenerative potential (10/) or showed discontinuity (12/) and thus were reconstructed with autologous sural nerve grafts. In four cases, a reconstructive procedure was intraoperatively abandoned as a result of the large extent of the lesion.

Thirty-six patients with an adequate follow-up period of at least 18 months were included in this study. Among those with external neurolysis, 73% (eight out of 11) showed a good functional outcome, obviating the need for a kick-up foot brace (M >or= 4). In the interfascicular neurolysis group, 71% (five out of seven) exhibited a similar outcome. In the grafted group, however, only 28% (five out of 18) obtained a functionally useful result dependent on graft length. A graft length under 6 cm led to a functionally useful outcome in 44% of patients (four out of nine) compared with 11% (one out of nine) when the graft length was greater than or equal to 6 cm. In six patients, muscle-tendon transfers were performed, resulting in strong, useful foot lift.

Peroneal nerve lesions lacking regenerative signs should be explored. A functionally useful result (M >or=4) was achieved in 72% of the patients with either external or internal neurolysis and in 28% of the patients after a nerve graft procedure. Patients in whom nerve surgery failed to reconstitute useful foot lift need to be evaluated for their suitability to undergo a tendon transfer procedure.