Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 5, 2026
04:35
Comparative Study of Simulation of Temperature Rise in Ring Main Unit
Published on: July 5, 2024
Designing for the home: a comparative study of support aids for central heating systems
J Sauer1, D G Wastell, C Schmeink
1Department of Psychology, Rue de Faucigny 2, University of Fribourg, 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland. juergen.sauer@unifr.ch
Applied Ergonomics
|April 25, 2008
Summary
Predictive displays significantly improved user performance in managing central heating systems, unlike other support types. Users also preferred predictive and status displays, impacting system design recommendations.
Area of Science:
- Human-Computer Interaction
- Building Energy Management
- Cognitive Systems Engineering
Background:
- Effective management of central heating systems is crucial for energy efficiency and user comfort.
- Existing system support interfaces may not optimally aid users in complex control tasks.
- Understanding user interaction with system support is key to improving performance.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate how different enhanced system support features influence user performance in managing a central heating system.
- To evaluate the impact of historical, predictive, and instructional displays on user behavior and system outcomes.
- To gather subjective user feedback on the usability and effectiveness of various support interfaces.
Main Methods:
- Utilized a computer-based simulation (CHESS V2.0) of a central heating system.
- Assigned 75 participants to operational scenarios with varying support conditions.
- Collected objective performance data (energy consumption, information sampling, control behavior) and subjective user evaluations.
Main Results:
- Predictive displays demonstrated significant performance gains in system management.
- No performance benefits were observed with historical or instructional display types.
- Users highly valued predictive and status displays over other interface options.
Conclusions:
- Predictive display features are beneficial for enhancing user performance in central heating system management.
- System designers should prioritize incorporating predictive and status display functionalities.
- User-centered design principles, informed by empirical data, are essential for effective building energy management systems.
Related Concept Videos
01:25Design Example: Designing a Residential Plumbing System
The design of residential plumbing systems requires carefully evaluating water demand, flow rates, and pressure dynamics to ensure both efficiency and reliability. The nature of water flow within pipes is defined by its Reynolds number, which classifies flow as either laminar (smooth) or turbulent.
02:44Heating and Cooling Curves
When a substance—isolated from its environment—is subjected to heat changes, corresponding changes in temperature and phase of the substance is observed; this is graphically represented by heating and cooling curves.
For instance, the addition of heat raises the temperature of a solid; the amount of heat absorbed depends on the heat capacity of the solid (q = mcsolidΔT). According to thermochemistry, the relation between the amount of heat absorbed or released by a substance, q, and its...
For instance, the addition of heat raises the temperature of a solid; the amount of heat absorbed depends on the heat capacity of the solid (q = mcsolidΔT). According to thermochemistry, the relation between the amount of heat absorbed or released by a substance, q, and its...
01:14Mechanisms of Heat Transfer
Heat transfer between the human body and its environment occurs through four main mechanisms: conduction, convection, radiation, and evaporation.
Conduction, accounting for approximately 3% of body heat loss at rest, is the process of exchanging heat between molecules of two materials in direct contact. This can result in both heat loss and gain. For instance, when the body is submerged in water, which conducts heat 20 times more effectively than air, it can either lose or gain significant heat.
Conduction, accounting for approximately 3% of body heat loss at rest, is the process of exchanging heat between molecules of two materials in direct contact. This can result in both heat loss and gain. For instance, when the body is submerged in water, which conducts heat 20 times more effectively than air, it can either lose or gain significant heat.
01:14Mechanisms of Heat Transfer I
Just as interesting as the effects of heat transfer on a system are the methods by which the heat transfer occur. Whenever there is a temperature difference, heat transfer occurs. It may occur rapidly, such as through a cooking pan, or slowly, such as through the walls of a picnic ice box. So many processes involve heat transfer that it is hard to imagine a situation where no heat transfer occurs. Yet, every heat transfer takes place by only three methods: conduction, convection, and radiation.
01:20Mechanisms of Heat Transfer II
In convection, thermal energy is carried by the large-scale flow of matter. Ocean currents and large-scale atmospheric circulation, which result from the buoyancy of warm air and water, transfer hot air from the tropics toward the poles and cold air from the poles toward the tropics. The Earth’s rotation interacts with those flows, causing the observed eastward flow of air in the temperate zones. Convection dominates heat transfer by air, and the amount of available space for the airflow...
01:24Single Pipe Systems
In pipe flow analysis, problems are typically categorized into three types — Type I, Type II, and Type III — based on the known parameters and the desired outcome. Each type of problem addresses specific engineering requirements using fluid properties, pipe characteristics, and operational conditions.
In a Type I problem, fluid properties (density and viscosity), pipe characteristics (including diameter, length, and surface roughness), and the flow rate or average velocity are known. The...
In a Type I problem, fluid properties (density and viscosity), pipe characteristics (including diameter, length, and surface roughness), and the flow rate or average velocity are known. The...