Morbidity and mortality after liver resection for benign and malignant hepatobiliary lesions

Although most partial liver resections are performed for malignant lesions, an increasing contingent of benign lesions is also considered for surgery. The aim was to assess post-operative morbidity and mortality after liver resection for benign hepatobiliary lesions in comparison with outcome after resection of malignant lesions.

A total of 286 liver resections were undertaken between January 1992 and December 2004. After exclusion of resection for bile duct tumours or hepatocellular carcinoma, 205 partial liver resections were retrospectively analysed.

Patients with benign lesions comprised 34% of the group (n=70). Benign lesions mainly consisted of focal nodular hyperplasia (n=12; 17%) and liver haemangiomas (11; 15.7%). The malignant lesions consisted of colorectal tumour metastases (n=121; 89%). Patients with benign lesions predominantly underwent minor liver resections (66 vs. 47%; P=0.013). The overall post-operative morbidity occurred in 31% (64/205). Major morbidity occurred in 16% (22/135) in the malignant group compared with 9% (6/70) in the benign group (P=0.099). No differences were seen in major post-operative morbidity in the earlier period compared with the later period (14 vs. 14.3%, P=0.950). In multivariate analysis, only presence of comorbidity (P=0.017), prolonged surgical procedure (P=0.021) and surgical irradicality (P=0.039) maintained significance as independent risk factors for major morbidity.

Limited liver resections for the treatment of a wide range of benign hepatobiliary lesions are associated with low morbidity and no mortality. However, the indications must be assessed with care. The presence of comorbidity, prolonged surgical time and incomplete resections were associated with major morbidity.