Low-lying isomers of the B9(-) boron cluster: the planar molecular wheel versus three-dimensional structures

The B(9)(-) cluster was found previously to be an unprecedented molecular wheel containing an octacoordinate planar boron with D(8h) symmetry in a combined photoelectron spectroscopy (PES) and theoretical study [H. J. Zhai et al., Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 42, 6004 (2003)]. However, the PES spectra of B(9)(-) exhibit minor features that cannot be explained by the global minimum D(8h) structure, suggesting possible contributions from low-lying isomers at finite temperatures. Here we present Car-Parrinello molecular dynamics with simulated annealing simulations to fully explore the potential energy surface of B(9)(-) and search for low-lying isomers that may account for the minor PES features. We performed density functional theory (DFT) calculations with different exchange-correlation functionals and ab initio calculations at various levels of theory with different basis sets. Two three-dimensional low-lying isomers were found, both of C(s) symmetry, 6.29 (C(s)-2) and 10.23 (C(s)-1) kcal/mol higher in energy than the D(8h) structure at the highest CCSD(T) level of theory. Calculated detachment transitions from the C(s)-2 isomer are in excellent agreement with the minor features observed in the PES spectra of B(9)(-). The B(9)(-) cluster proves to be a challenge for most DFT methods and the calculated relative energies strongly depend on the exchange-correlation functionals, providing an excellent example for evaluating the accuracies of various DFT methods.