Prospective study of urine cytology screening for BK polyoma virus replication in renal transplant recipients

BK virus (BKV) may be associated with interstitial nephritis in renal transplant recipients and this can lead to irreversible chronic allograft dysfunction. Early diagnosis of BKV nephropathy determines its progress because no specific antiviral therapy exists. Urine cytology, detection of viral DNA in urine or blood and renal biopsy are the main diagnostic tools. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the use of urine cytology for diagnosis of BKV replication in renal graft recipients.

We studied 32 de novo renal transplant recipients prospectively with sequential urine samples for a period of 1 year. Thin-Prep methodology was used to prepare the slides. Cytology results were correlated with polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in urine and blood.

Decoy cells indicative of BKV infection were detected in 14 (7.3%) of the 190 urine samples derived from 11 recipients. In three cases with positive decoy cells, BK viraemia and viruria were simultaneously identified. In a further three cases, BKV active replication was confirmed in urine by both cytology and PCR.

Urine cytology is an easy and rapid method of detecting decoy cells in cases where renal biopsy is not possible. However, the low incidence of detection of decoy cells in the present study, together with poor correlation with PCR results, questions its sensitivity and specificity in diagnosing BKV reactivation.