The natural history of suspected scaphoid fractures

Clinically suspected scaphoid fractures are common injuries. The authors prospectively followed up, by serial radiography and bone scanning, 23 patients who had a history of trauma to the carpus and associated localized tenderness to the anatomic "snuff box": in 15 patients the radiographs and bone scans were negative; in 5 the radiograph was equivocal and the bone scan positive. The authors concluded that patients with clinically suspected scaphoid fractures and negative radiographs can be treated symptomatically without immobilization in a cast. Patients with equivocal radiographs should be assumed to have a fractured scaphoid and treated accordingly.