Median nerve excursion in response to wrist movement after endoscopic and open carpal tunnel release

To compare the perioperative kinematic effects of endoscopic versus open carpal tunnel release on longitudinal excursion (gliding) and volar displacement (bowstringing) of the median nerve at the wrist region in patients with idiopathic primary carpal tunnel syndrome.

Sixteen hands of 13 patients were randomly assigned into 2 groups (group 1, endoscopic; group 2, open carpal tunnel release). For the measurement of gliding and bowstringing of the median nerve, a metallic marker was used. Before and after the division of the transverse carpal ligament, longitudinal excursion and volar displacement of the median nerve were calculated based on fluoroscopic imaging for each wrist. Movement was analyzed for the measurement of the marker locations.

The mean prerelease median nerve excursion during wrist range of motion was 20 mm (range, 10-28) in group 1 and 21 mm (range, 16-31 mm) in group 2. The mean postrelease median nerve excursion during wrist range of motion was 20 mm (range, 13-29) in group 1 and 18 mm (range, 8-26 mm) in group 2. There was no statistically significant difference in pre- and postrelease longitudinal excursion changes between the groups (p = .916 and p = .674, respectively). The mean prerelease volar displacement of the median nerve during wrist range of motion was 3 mm in group 1 and 4 mm in group 2; the postrelease mean values were 2 mm and 5 mm, respectively. There was no statistically significant difference between the groups with regard to pre- and postrelease volar displacement changes of the median nerve (p = .372 and p = .103, respectively).

This study demonstrated that the endoscopic release and open carpal tunnel release produce similar perioperative effects on longitudinal and volar movements of the median nerve.