Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jun 29, 2026

Mouse In Vivo Placental Targeted CRISPR Manipulation
Published on: April 14, 2023
Periviable babies: Italian suggestions for the ethical debate
Maria Serenella Pignotti1, Gianpaolo Donzelli
1Neonatal Medicine, A. Meyer Children Hospital, University of Florence, Florence, Italy. m.pignotti@meyer.it
Insights
This study reviews survival and morbidity rates for high-risk infants born at the threshold of viability. It led to the
Area of Science:
- Neonatal intensive care and high-risk infant outcomes.
- Medical ethics in neonatal care.
- Perinatal viability and treatment guidelines.
Background:
- Advancements in medical technology have improved outcomes for high-risk infants.
- Neonatal intensive care raises ethical considerations, particularly for infants near the threshold of viability.
- International guidelines exist, with a consensus to withhold resuscitation below 23 weeks' gestational age and provide intensive care from 25 weeks.
Framework:
- Development of a consensus document, the 'Carta di Firenze', to guide the management of threatened births.
- Focus on infants with a gestational age of 25 completed weeks or less.
- Excludes issues of pediatric euthanasia and eugenetics.
Implementation:
- Review of international studies on survival and morbidity rates.
- Analysis of international guidelines and practice recommendations.
- Submission of the consensus document to Italian Scientific Societies for approval.
Implications:
- Provides suggestions for the initial management of threatened births near the threshold of viability.
- Aims to protect both infant and mother from undue suffering.
- Offers recommendations for clinical practice in neonatal care.
Abstract:
With the advancement of medical technology, the outcomes for high-risk infants have greatly improved. However, hand and hand with the more positive result of saving neonates, modern neonatal intensive care has also brought to light several issues regarding the ethical grounds in infant care. One of the greatest problems concerns newborns at the threshold of viability. Treatment guidelines have been formulated for these babies in different countries all around the world and there is the general consensus to withhold resuscitation in neonates when gestational age in less than, or equal to 23 weeks, with intensive care ensured for infants at 25 weeks' gestational age. In order to provide helpful suggestions during the initial management of the threatened birth of an infant with a gestational age of 25 completed weeks or less, we conducted a study for reviewing international studies on survival and morbidity rates, international guidelines and practice recommendations. This gave rise to the creation of a consensus document subsequently submitted to the Italian Scientific Societies for approval. The 'Carta di Firenze' does not attempt to deal with the problems related to pediatric euthanasia or eugenetics: its aim is to protect the infant and the mother from undue suffering although addressing recommendations for the work of clinicians.
Related Concept Videos
CRISPR
Ethical Issues
Ethical Concerns in Healthcare:
Ethics and Bioethics
Ethical Dilemmas I
Let us explore some examples to understand the potentially complex moral decisions nurses face.
Take the case of caring for minors, particularly in areas related to reproductive...
Ethical Dilemmas II
Ethics in Research
