Prosthetic heart valve evaluation in vitro: critical aspects of data comparability

The technology of heart valve substitution has considerably improved in the last few years, but its reliability after implantation is still not good enough, hence the need to study new valve design and improve quality testing. Different pulse duplicators are used for heart valve testing, but the results depend very much on the system adopted and the measurement protocol. Tests on two pulse duplicators currently used at the Biomedical Engineering Laboratory at the Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Rome, are reported here. The most significant parameters for valve evaluation were measured following each system's own protocol. Attention was focused on vascular load tuning when setting up the system and on the relationship between drive unit flow waveform and valve regurgitation and energy loss measurements. Standardization criteria must be defined in order to ensure the reliable comparability of in vitro testing results.