Correlation of an audible fourth heart sound with level of diastolic dysfunction
David G Meyers1, Innessa T Porter, Kirstie A Schneider
1Division of Cardiovascular Diseases, Department of Internal Medicine, Kansas University School of Medicine, Kansas City, Kansas 66160, USA. dmeyers@kumc.edu
Insights
The fourth heart sound (S4) is not a reliable indicator of left ventricular (LV) diastolic dysfunction. Its presence and absence do not consistently correlate with the severity of diastolic dysfunction.
Area of Science:
- Cardiology
- Cardiac Physiology
Background:
- The clinical utility of the fourth heart sound (S4) in diagnosing left ventricular (LV) diastolic dysfunction is debated among experts.
- Disagreement exists regarding the S4's effectiveness as a marker for LV diastolic dysfunction.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the correlation between the prevalence of the S4 and the severity of LV diastolic dysfunction.
- To determine the diagnostic accuracy of the S4 for identifying LV diastolic dysfunction.
Main Methods:
- A study involving 106 patients in sinus rhythm was conducted, excluding those with specific cardiac conditions.
- Investigators blinded to diastolic function status auscultated for S4 in participants.
- Diastolic function was assessed by other cardiologists using mitral inflow, tissue, and pulmonary vein Doppler echocardiography.
Main Results:
- S4 was detected in 35% with normal function, 42% with mild, and 70% with moderate diastolic dysfunction.
- Notably, S4 was absent in all patients with severe diastolic dysfunction (P = 0.052).
- The S4 demonstrated low sensitivity (43%), specificity (65%), and accuracy (53%) for distinguishing normal from abnormal diastolic function.
Conclusions:
- The S4 is neither sensitive nor specific for diagnosing LV diastolic dysfunction.
- The S4 sound is common in the elderly with normal function and absent in severe dysfunction, rendering it an unreliable indicator.
Background:
Expert physicians disagree on the usefulness of the fourth heart sound (S4) as an indicator of left ventricular (LV) diastolic dysfunction.
Methods:
We correlated prevalence of the S4 with level of severity of LV diastolic dysfunction. From 551 consecutive echocardiography and Doppler studies, 106 patients in sinus rhythm but without cardiac conduction abnormalities, prosthetic or abnormal valves, or high blood flow states were auscultated by 3 investigators blinded to the participants' diastolic function as determined by 3 other cardiologists using mitral inflow, tissue, and pulmonary vein Doppler interrogation.
Results:
Diastolic function was normal in 46 participants, 45 had mild, 10 had moderate, and 5 had severe diastolic dysfunction. S4 was audible in 35% with normal function, 42% with mild, 70% with moderate, and none with severe dysfunction (P = 0.052). Sensitivity was 43%, specificity 65%, and accuracy of 53% for discriminating normal from abnormal function. S4 is neither sensitive nor specific, is common but not normal in the elderly, may be absent with severe diastolic dysfunction, and therefore is not a useful indicator of LV diastolic dysfunction.
Conclusions:
The S4 is not an accurate indicator of diastolic dysfunction, as it is present in many persons with normal LV function and is absent in those with severe LV dysfunction.
Related Concept Videos
Cardiovascular System Abnormal Findings II: Auscultation
Abnormal Heart Sounds
Gallops:
Assessment of the Cardiovascular System IV: Auscultation
Normal Heart Sounds
S1 (First Heart Sound)-
S1 is made by the closure of the mitral and tricuspid valves (atrioventricular valves), marking the beginning of systole.
S2 (Second Heart Sound)-
S2 is made by the closure of the aortic and pulmonic valves (semilunar valves), marking the end of the systole.
Heart Sounds
Auscultation is the process of listening to these internal body sounds using a stethoscope. The heart produces four types of sounds, but only two—S1 and S2—can usually be heard with a stethoscope.
S1, also known as the "lub" sound, is caused by the closure of atrioventricular (A-V) valves at the...
Korotkoff Sounds
During blood pressure assessment, inflating the cuff 30 millimeters of mercury above the patient's systolic blood pressure...
Aortic Regurgitation II: Clinical Features and Diagnostic Tests
Heart Failure IV: Classification and Diagnostic Evaluation
