A comparison between total hip replacement for osteonecrosis and degenerative joint disease

There has been some reluctance to perform total hip replacement on younger patients with osteonecrosis because of the poor results reported in the earlier literature. To determine the extent to which advances in surgical technique and prosthesis design have led to improved results, we evaluated 203 total hip replacements performed for osteonecrosis and compared them to 300 performed for degenerative joint disease. The failure rate for all femoral and acetabular components combined was 3.7% (22 of 600), in degenerative joint disease and 10.1% (41 of 406) in osteonecrosis. However, results with the most recently used acetabular component, the noncemented HGP-1, were markedly improved over earlier components in both conditions, with only 1 failure in 235 hips (0.4%). The increased survivorship of THR in osteonecrosis with improved component design and surgical technique is encouraging. Total hip replacement is a good option for patients with advanced stages of osteonecrosis, and similar surgical indications should be used for patients with degenerative joint disease and other disorders.