Nature of forces stabilizing the transmembrane protein bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane

Analysis of the far-ultraviolet solution and the oriented-film circular dichroic (CD) spectra of the purple membrane (PM) has indicated that the alpha-helical segments of its sole protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR) can undergo a significant tilting from the normal to the membrane plane during light-dependent hydroxylamine-mediated bleaching of the bR. However, this drastic change in tertiary structure is free of any observable secondary structural changes. This phenomenon can provide an excellent means for studying the relative contributions of forces responsible for the stability of this transmembrane protein within the membrane bilayer. Perturbation of the PM by varying degrees of papain digestion (resulting in changes in the bR ranging from only an elimination of the long COOH-terminal tail to the additional eliminations of the short NH(2)-terminal tail and a number of linkage amino acids between the helical segments of the bR) and by chemical cross-linking with dimethyl adipimidate (resulting primarily in the formation of intramolecular cross-links) resulted in a significant increase in this bleaching-induced tilting in all cases except the one in which only the COOH-tail was eliminated. The most severe perturbation (2-wk papain digestion) increased the net tilt angle per segment from 24 to 39 degrees with no indication of any secondary structural changes. Although these perturbations drastically reduced the structural stability of the bR to bleaching, they caused virtually no observable changes in the intramolecular structure of the bR or the supramolecular structure of the PM based on analysis of extensive absorption, linear dichroic, and CD spectra. In addition, study of the bleaching rates for the perturbed PM samples indicated that a linear correlation exists between the calculated initial bleaching rates and the net tilt angles.Considering the forces generally assumed to account for the stability of transmembrane proteins in membranes, (a) intersegmental hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions, (b) electrostatic interactions between hydrophilic polypeptide segments extending outside the bilayer and the many charged lipid heads of the bilayer, and (c) hydrophobic interactions, it is clear that the results of the bleaching experiments eliminate all but perhaps the last as contributing significantly to the bR stability in the PM. Furthermore, they provide more compelling evidence than previously available that the bR is capable of undergoing relatively large retinyldiene-controlled tertiary structural changes and that the chromophoric retinal serves as the most important factor in the native bR structural stability. This dynamic view of the bR bears directly on models proposed for bR function, favoring those in which protein structural metastability, rather than rigidity, is an essential factor. The proteinquake or deformation wave model proposed by this laboratory falls into this category.