Brachytherapy versus cystectomy in solitary bladder cancer: a case control, multicentre, East-Netherlands study

Comparing the outcome of surgery and brachytherapy-based radiotherapy in patients with solitary T1G3/T2 bladder tumour in, a retrospective case-control study, because efforts for a randomised clinical trial comparing these modalities have failed.

Cystectomy group. Patients were selected using the pathological registration system (PALGA). 289 cases of TURT followed by cystectomy, indicated by a muscle--invading bladder tumour were performed in three East-Netherlands medical centres between 1991 and 2001. Out of this group 179 patients with clinical T2N0M0 bladder tumour were selected. All the consecutive files were analysed by a urologist and a radiation oncologist and 65 of those patients (mean age 63.7 years) would have been eligible for brachytherapy, based on an initial analysis: cystoscopy estimated tumour size, post-TURT pathological report, completed by CT-scan and/or, MRI-scan. A final pathological report after radical cystectomy was not considered for patients' selection. Brachytherapy group. Patients were selected using a prospective registration study aiming at determination of our treatment results. 89 Patients (mean age 68.4 years) underwent TURT followed by a course of external beam irradiation and interstitial brachytherapy from 1983 till 2005 in the Arnhem Radiotherapy Institute.

The median follow-up for the brachytherapy group was 5.7 years (range 0.2-21.4 years), for the cystectomy group was 5.05 years (range: 0.04-16.8 years). No difference in disease-specific survival (DSS) could be detected with a 5- and 10-year DSS of 71% and 66% in the brachytherapy group and 60% and 57% in the cystectomy group, respectively. Five-year overall survival (OS) was 57% in the brachytherapy group and 52% in the cystectomy group, however, the 10-year OS was better in the cystectomy than in the brachytherapy group (42% and 33%, respectively). This is caused by the significant age difference in favour of the cystectomy group. Cystectomy-free survival in the brachytherapy group was 70%.

Radical cystectomy is the treatment of choice for patients with muscle-invasive bladder carcinoma. However, in a selected patient population a bladder sparing treatment, i.e. a combination of transurethral tumour resection (TURT), external beam irradiation and interstitial brachytherapy, can be applied successfully. This concerns a solitary, T1G3 or T2 bladder tumour, with a diameter<5 cm.