Immunomodulation of kidney and heart transplants by anti-idiotypic antibodies

To explore the possibility that circulating HLA antigens from the graft and anti-anti-HLA (anti-idiotypic) antibodies influence the long-term survival of renal and cardiac allografts, analysis of 330 renal allograft recipients and 174 recipients of cardiac allografts was conducted. Anti-donor-HLA antibodies (Ab1) present before or after transplantation are associated with graft failure, whereas irrelevant anti-HLA antibodies had no impact on actuarial graft survival. Ab1 may be uncovered by dissociation of immune complexes and depletion of soluble antigens with monoclonal antibody-coated magnetic beads. Of the 421 sera tested from 65 heart recipients, 97 showed Ab1 before depletion and 178 after depletion; similar rise in positive sera was seen in 39 renal transplant recipients. Three distinct patterns of appearance of Ab1 and Ab2 (anti-Ab1 antibody) were recognized. Patients with cyclic variations of Ab1 in association with Ab2 had 100% graft survival, whereas patients with cyclic variations of Ab1 but no detectable Ab2 had 2-year graft survival of 36% for kidneys and 71% for hearts. Presence of Ab1 in all sera after transplantation led to 47% and 56% 2-year renal and heart allograft survival, respectively.