Imaging of implant needles for real-time HDR-brachytherapy prostate treatment using biplane ultrasound transducers

Ultrasound imaging is becoming increasingly important in prostate brachytherapy. In high-dose-rate (HDR) real-time planning procedures the definition of the implant needles is often performed by transrectal ultrasound. This article describes absolute measurements of the visibility and accuracy of manual detection of implant needle tips and compares measurement results of different biplane ultrasound systems in transversal and longitudinal (i.e., sagittal) ultrasound modes. To obtain a fixed coordinate system and stable conditions the measurements were carried out in a water tank using a dedicated marker system. Needles were manually placed in the phantom until the observer decided by the real-time ultrasound image that the zero position was reached. A comparison of three different ultrasound systems yielded an offset between 0.8 and 3.1 mm for manual detection of the needle tip in ultrasound images by one observer. The direction of the offset was discovered to be in the proximal direction, i.e., the actual needle position was located more distally compared to the ultrasound-based definition. In the second part of the study, the ultrasound anisotropy of trocar implant needles is reported. It was shown that the integrated optical density in a region of interest around the needle tip changes with needle rotation. Three peaks were observed with a phase angle of 120 degrees. Peaks appear not only in transversal but also in longitudinal ultrasound images, with a phase shift of 60 degrees. The third section of this study shows results of observer dependent influences on needle tip detection in sagittal ultrasound images considering needle rotation. These experiments were carried out using the marker system in a water tank. The needle tip was placed exactly at the position z=0 mm. It was found that different users tend to differently interpret the same ultrasound images. The needle tip was manually detected five times in the ultrasound images by three experienced observers at positions (+/- standard deviation) -0.53 +/- 0.16, -0.16 +/- 0.14, and -0.30 +/- 0.16 mm using a gain of 15 dB. The minus sign indicates that the needle tips were detected more proximally than the actual position of the needle tip. When using a gain of -15 dB the mean values of two observers resulted in -0.62 +/- 0.08 and -0.51 +/- 0.12 mm. Additionally an alternative approach to the direct needle tip definition was investigated. Two observers detected the solid part of the needle tip in sagittal images. This solid part, often named as "dead space end," is the distance between the needle tip and the beginning of the hollow part of the implant needle. The dead space end is 6.2 mm for the investigated needle type. Two users found mean values of -6.70 +/- 0.16 and -7.00 +/- 0.06 mm, respectively, for 15 dB gain and -6.90 +/- 0.09 and -7.02 +/- 0.06 mm using the -15 dB gain setting. The results show that ultrasound-based needle tip definition in sagittal viewing mode is accurate. The inter- and intraobserver errors should, however, be taken into account. A lower gain setting of the ultrasound system reduces the intraobserver error.