Miniature pigs as an animal model for implant research: bone regeneration in critical-size defects

Standardized experimental investigations determining the critical-size defect (CSD) in the mandible of miniature pigs are still lacking. The aim of the present study was to obtain information about the new bone formation in created defects of varying sizes.

Marginal resection of the alveolar crest of the lower jaw was performed in 3 female miniature pigs. The animals used in the study were 3 years of age and weighed approximately 55 kg. For histologic evaluation the dental implants were harvested with the surrounding bone tissue 10 weeks after implant placement. For this, bone segments including the implants were removed from each side of the mandible. The sizes of the resected bone blocks varied, showing the following volumes: 10.1 cm(3), 4.2 cm(3), and 1.9 cm(3). Periosteal coverage of the defects was performed. Computerized tomography (CT) of the skull of the miniature pig was performed immediately after the surgical procedure as well as 6 weeks later using a 64-channel mult-slice scanner.

The CT showed that 6 weeks after obtaining the biopsies, the filling of the defects with new bone varied. The percentage of newly formed bone in relation to the size of the original defect was 57.4% for the small- and 87.2% for the middle-sized defect. The large-sized defect showed 75.5% newly formed bone compared with baseline.

Considering the amount of new bone formation found within this study, it is questionable if the critical defect size of 5 cm(3) stated in the literature is valid. Further research concerning the mandibular model in minipigs is required and more refinement needed to assure a standardized CSD, allowing qualitative and quantitative evaluation of bone grafts and bone graft substitutes.