Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jun 17, 2026

Culturing and Maintaining Clostridium difficile in an Anaerobic Environment
Published on: September 14, 2013
Presence of soil-dwelling clostridia in commercial powdered infant formulas
Jason R Barash1, Jennifer K Hsia, Stephen S Arnon
1Infant Botulism Treatment and Prevention Program, Division of Communicable Disease Control, Center for Infectious Diseases, California Department of Public Health, Richmond, CA 94804, USA.
Insights
Clostridium spores, including Clostridium sporogenes, were found in U.S. powdered infant formula (PIF). While no neurotoxigenic clostridia were detected, this indicates a potential risk for infant botulism from PIF.
Area of Science:
- Microbiology
- Food Safety
- Public Health
Background:
- Infant botulism cases linked to powdered infant formula (PIF) in the UK prompted further investigation.
- Clostridium botulinum was previously isolated from PIF associated with infant botulism.
Purpose of the Study:
- To determine the presence and types of clostridial spores in U.S.-manufactured PIF.
- To assess the potential risk of infant botulism associated with U.S. PIF.
Main Methods:
- Anaerobic culture of 30 PIF samples ingested by infants with botulism.
- Culture of 9 market-purchased PIF samples.
- Identification and enumeration of isolated clostridia using standard microbiologic and molecular methods.
Main Results:
- Clostridial spores were detected in 17% of PIF samples ingested by patients and 78% of market-purchased samples.
- Clostridium sporogenes was the most frequently isolated species, followed by Clostridium butyricum and other soil-dwelling clostridial species.
- No neurotoxigenic clostridia were found; spore counts ranged from 1.1 to >23 per 100g.
Conclusions:
- Clostridium sporogenes shares physiological similarities with proteolytic Clostridium botulinum strains and has a similar environmental reservoir.
- The presence of C. sporogenes and other potentially pathogenic clostridia in U.S. PIF suggests a potential risk for neurotoxigenic clostridial spores.
- While neurotoxigenic strains were not found, the presence of related species warrants continued monitoring of PIF for infant safety.
Objective:
Because Clostridium botulinum was isolated from powdered infant formula (PIF) fed to an infant in the United Kingdom who subsequently developed infant botulism and from unopened PIF from the same manufacturer, we tested PIF manufactured in the United States for the presence of clostridial spores.
Study Design:
Thirty PIF ingested by 19 California infants with botulism within 4 weeks of onset of illness (48% of all patients fed PIF during study) in 2006-2007 were cultured anaerobically to isolate clostridia. All isolated clostridia were identified to the species level and enumerated with standard microbiologic and molecular methods.
Results:
Five of 30 (17%) PIF samples ingested by patients contained clostridial spores. Spores were also found in 7 of 9 (78%) market-purchased PIF samples. Clostridium sporogenes was isolated most frequently, followed by Clostridium butyricum and at least 10 other soil-dwelling clostridial species. No neurotoxigenic clostridia were isolated. The most probable number of clostridial spores in PIF ranged between 1.1 to >23 per 100 g.
Conclusions:
With the notable exception of production of botulinum neurotoxin, C sporogenes is physiologically comparable with proteolytic strains of C botulinum, and both share the same natural reservoir (soils and dust worldwide). The isolation of C sporogenes and potentially pathogenic clostridia from U.S.-manufactured PIF suggests that neurotoxigenic clostridial spores have the potential to be present in these products.
Related Concept Videos
Development of Human Microbiota
Bacterial Phylum Firmicutes
Microbes in the Production of Fermented Foods
Microbes in Food Production
Bacterial Flora of the Large Intestine
The normal gut flora of the colon plays a critical role in generating essential vitamins such as vitamins K, B5, and B7.

