Solvation effects in calculated electrostatic association free energies for the C3d-CR2 complex and comparison with...

The complement system is an integral part of the innate immune system that participates in the clearance of pathogens from the body. The association between complement protein fragment C3d and B or T cell-receptor complement receptor (CR) 2 represents a crucial link between innate and adaptive immunities. The goal of this study is to predict association abilities of C3d and CR2 mutants by theoretically calculating electrostatic free energies of association and to assess the importance of solvation effects in the calculations. We demonstrate that calculated solvation free energy differences and Coulombic free energies of association are more sensitive than electrostatic free energies of association in solution and, thus, more accurate in predicting previously published experimental data for the association abilities (relative to the parent proteins) of specific C3d and CR2 mutants. We show that a proportional relationship exists between the predicted solvation free energy differences and the experimental data, while an inversely proportional relationship exists between the predicted Coulombic free energies of association and the experimental data. Our results yield new insights into the physicochemical properties underlying C3d-CR2 association. We discuss the predictive validity of Coulombic, solvation, and solution electrostatic free energies of association and the generalization of our method for theoretical mutagenesis studies of other systems. This is a basic study, aimed toward improving our understanding of the theoretical basis of immune system regulation at the molecular level. Such insight can serve as the groundwork for the design of regulators with tailored properties, vaccines, and other biotechnology products.