The European experience in poultry welfare--a decade ahead

Farm animal welfare is a major issue in Europe, which resulted in regulations and development of research dedicated to animal welfare, especially on standard poultry production, which is often considered as resulting in very poor welfare. The effect of selection is also often questioned. Indeed, capacities of adaptation have been very little considered during the first years of commercial selection and thus have been reduced. Nowadays, a much greater importance is given to welfare-related traits and genomic selection should alleviate the need for their measurements in the short-term. However, the choice of the fittest selection criteria is still to be made. Because behavioral traits are highly dependent on environment, general reactivity may be more efficient. For example, selection against undesirable behavior such as feather pecking has been proven to be efficient, but selection for reduced mortality rates in collective cages proved to be preferable. Most often, selection should not exacerbate extreme values, which are most often detrimental, as in the case of social motivation, which, when increased to too large of an extent, results in increased aggressivity. Moreover, a general propensity will not result in overall improvement; for example, reducing fearfulness has positive effects but does not modify response to social stress. Detrimental effects on other traits may also be observed: although genetic resistance to diseases should increase animal welfare, it may also result in increased frequency of silent carriers and in turn to human transmission. Indeed, an optimum must be found. Studying lines selected for or against these traits will be of great help to choose the best strategy of selection. Another and longer term concern should be on links with other production traits but also on sustainability, which will probably be of greater importance in the coming years.