Hypervascular liver masses on contrast-enhanced ultrasound: the importance of washout

The objective of our study was to determine the role of negative enhancement (washout), its presence and timing, in the differential diagnosis of hypervascular liver masses on contrast-enhanced ultrasound.

One-hundred forty-six hypervascular liver lesions (mean size, 3.9 cm; range, 1.0-17.0 cm) were evaluated with contrast-enhanced ultrasound over a 6-month period. Seventy-four were benign (29 hemangiomas, 31 focal nodular hyperplasia [FNH] lesions, seven adenomas, five inflammatory lesions, two other) and 72, malignant (41 hepatocellular carcinomas [HCCs], 25 metastases, six other). Two independent reviewers retrospectively recorded the presence and timing of washout in the portal venous phase, observing until 4 minutes after injection, of a contrast agent (perflutren microspheres). Diagnoses were confirmed by histopathology (n = 68) or clinicoradiologic follow-up (n = 78). Timing of washout was compared between types of lesion using Fisher's exact test.

Washout occurred in both benign (27/74, 36%) and malignant (70/72, 97%) lesions but was more frequently seen in malignancy (p < 0.001) (kappa = 0.91). Metastases showed more rapid washout than HCCs (p < 0.001): 20 of 25 metastases showed washout by 30 seconds after injection and 23 of 41 HCCs, later than 75 seconds. All malignant lesions without washout were HCCs (2/41). Among the benign lesions, all five inflammatory lesions showed rapid washout before 75 seconds and six of seven adenomas showed washout, mostly later than 75 seconds (5/6). Washout also occurred in hemangiomas (6/29) and FNH lesions (9/31), mostly later than 75 seconds after injection (12/15).

Hypervascular malignant lesions show washout except infrequent cases of HCC. Rapid washout characterizes metastases, whereas HCCs show variable, often slow, washout. However, washout is not unique to malignancy and may be seen in benign lesions.