Why we should be vigilant: drug cytotoxicity observed with in vitro transporter inhibition studies

Xiaowan Zheng1, Lei Diao, Sean Ekins

  • 1Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, School of Pharmacy, University of Maryland, 20 N. Pine Street, Baltimore, MD 21201, United States.

Insights

Cytotoxicity, not direct interaction, can cause apparent drug transporter inhibition in vitro. This finding is crucial for accurate drug development and avoiding false positives in transporter assays.

Area of Science:

  • Pharmacology
  • Cell Biology
  • Drug Discovery

Background:

  • In vitro drug-transporter inhibition assays often assume direct transporter interaction.
  • Alternative mechanisms reducing substrate uptake are less frequently investigated.
  • Solute carrier (SLC) transporters play vital roles in drug disposition and efficacy.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To investigate the link between drug transporter inhibition and drug cytotoxicity.
  • To evaluate the impact of cytotoxicity on in vitro assays for ASBT, OCTN2, and EAAT4 transporters.
  • To identify drugs where observed inhibition is due to cytotoxicity rather than direct transporter interaction.

Main Methods:

  • Selected 21 known ASBT or OCTN2 inhibitors for screening.
  • Assessed inhibitory potency against ASBT, OCTN2, and EAAT4 transporters in stable cell lines.
  • Evaluated drug cytotoxicity in parallel with transporter inhibition assays.
  • Utilized MDCK and HEK cell lines for transporter expression.

Main Results:

  • Twenty drugs exhibited apparent inhibition for OCTN2 and ASBT transporters.
  • Four dihydropyridine calcium channel blockers showed cytotoxicity in MDCK cells.
  • Cytotoxicity explained apparent OCTN2 inhibition for three drugs, reclassifying them as non-inhibitors.
  • Cytotoxicity moderately contributed to ASBT inhibition for these three drugs.
  • Three out of four drugs showing apparent EAAT4 inhibition had their effects explained by cytotoxicity.

Conclusions:

  • Drug cytotoxicity can be a significant mechanism causing false positives in in vitro transporter inhibition assays.
  • Cytotoxicity effects vary across different cell lines, impacting assay reliability.
  • Accurate assessment requires distinguishing direct transporter inhibition from cytotoxicity-induced effects.
  • This study highlights the importance of considering cytotoxicity in drug development and pharmacophore modeling.

Related Concept Videos

Pharmacokinetics: Drug–Drug Interactions01:25

Pharmacokinetics: Drug–Drug Interactions

Drug interactions occur when the pharmacological effect of one drug is altered by another substance, either enhancing or diminishing its activity. The drug whose activity is altered is known as the object drug, and the substance causing the alteration is called the agent drug or the precipitant. The net effects of these interactions are mostly undesirable, leading to decreased effectiveness or increased adverse effects. In rare cases, interactions can be beneficial, such as the enhanced...
Pharmacogenetics of Drug Transporters: P-Glycoprotein and Solute Carrier Transporters01:16

Pharmacogenetics of Drug Transporters: P-Glycoprotein and Solute Carrier Transporters

The pharmacogenetics of drug transporters is increasingly recognized as a critical factor influencing interindividual variability in drug absorption, distribution, and elimination. These membrane-bound proteins regulate drugs' movement across cellular barriers by actively pumping them out (efflux) or facilitating their uptake (influx). Among the major transporter families, ATP-binding cassette (ABC) and solute carrier (SLC) transporters play particularly prominent roles. Genetic polymorphisms...
Nonlinear Pharmacokinetics: Role of Transporters01:27

Nonlinear Pharmacokinetics: Role of Transporters

A drug's nonlinear kinetics can be influenced by a diverse range of transporter proteins that serve as crucial players in drug distribution. These transporters, found within cells, can enhance or reduce local drug concentrations by facilitating the influx or efflux of drugs. For instance, the expression of xenobiotic transporters can be influenced by factors such as age and gender, potentially impacting the linearity of drug response.
Polymorphisms occurring in drug transporters can alter...
Drug toxicity: Idiosyncratic Reactions01:16

Drug toxicity: Idiosyncratic Reactions

Idiosyncratic drug reactions represent abnormal chemical responses that vary significantly among individuals, ranging from extreme sensitivity to low doses to insensitivity to high doses. These reactions often occur due to the drug's covalent binding with serum proteins, forming a foreign hapten that triggers an immunotoxicological response. The variability in drug reactions has a strong pharmacogenetic foundation, with genetic differences crucial in how individuals metabolize drugs. For...
Hepatic Drug Clearance: Role of Transporters01:14

Hepatic Drug Clearance: Role of Transporters

In the liver and bile canaliculi, influx and efflux transporters modification can influence intrinsic clearance. Transporters play a significant role in moving drugs within liver cells. Elaborate models, such as the Biopharmaceutical Classification System (BCS), are essential to relate transporters to drug disposition. This system categorizes drugs into four classes based on solubility and permeability, providing insights into elimination routes and the effects of transporters following oral...
Drug toxicity: Drug–Drug Interaction01:30

Drug toxicity: Drug–Drug Interaction

Drug–drug interactions can precipitate toxicity through multiple mechanisms. Absorption interactions alter how drugs enter the body, exemplified when ranitidine increases the absorption of basic drugs, while cholestyramine decreases the levels of propranolol. Protein binding interactions occur when drugs share the same binding sites on plasma proteins. Drugs like aspirin and warfarin, when bound in excess, can lead to increased free drug concentrations, enhancing the potential for...