Evaluation of the V79 cell metabolic co-operation assay as a screen in vitro for developmental toxicants

Inhibition of intercellular communication is proposed to be one of several possible mechanisms of teratogenesis. 38 coded compounds were tested for their effect on intercellular communication in the V79 cell metabolic co-operation assay. Test chemicals were selected from a list of 47 agents recommended for the evaluation of assays in vitro for developmental toxicants. In addition to testing the effects of chemicals on intercellular communication, a separate cytotoxicity assay determined the concentration of each chemical that inhibited clonal expansion of V79 cells. Seven of the 29 designated teratogens were positive for inhibition of intercellular communication in the V79 assay. Additionally, four teratogens and one non-teratogen inhibited intercellular communication at only a single concentration or at cytotoxic concentrations and were scored as equivocal. Therefore, the sensitivity of the V79 assay for teratogens was 24% (seven of 29 teratogens tested positive), or 38% if the four equivocal chemicals are considered positive. None of the nine non-teratogens unequivocally inhibited intercellular communication, resulting in a specificity of 100%, which decreased to 89% when the single equivocal score was considered positive. The overall accuracy for correctly identifying teratogens and non-teratogens was 42% when equivocal chemicals were considered negative, and 50% if they were considered positive in the V79 assay. The results demonstrate that despite relatively low accuracy regarding a diverse group of developmental toxicants, chemicals that did inhibit intercellular communication under the present conditions had a high probability of being a teratogen. The low accuracy reported here contrasts with earlier reports on the assay and possible reasons for this are discussed.