Defunctioning stomas prior to chemoradiation for anal cancer are usually permanent

A few patients with anal cancer will require a defunctioning stoma prior to chemoradiotherapy (CRT). The purpose of this retrospective review was to determine the frequency with which a pretreatment stoma was subsequently reversed.

Between 1997 and 2007, 46/344 patients who were treated for anal cancer underwent a defunctioning stoma prior to CRT. Thirty-five of these were treated with curative intent.

Of the 35 patients, 16 patients had T4, 17 T3 and 2 T2 disease. Sixteen were node positive. The average tumour size was 7 cm. The median interval between stoma formation and CRT was 6 (4-20) weeks. The median follow up was 26 (2-80) months. A defunctioning stoma was performed for rectovaginal fistula or risk of fistula in 18 and severe local symptoms in 17. Seven (20%) patients had the stoma reversed subsequently. The reasons for nonreversal were progressive disease (n = 9), persistent fistula (n = 3), predicted poor function (n = 4), cavity formation (n = 1), fibrosis (n = 3), death from another cause (n = 2), patient choice (n = 3) and salvage surgery (n = 2). The overall 3-year survival was only 48%, explained by the advanced stage of disease at presentation.

Most patients who undergo a defunctioning stoma before CRT will not undergo subsequent reversal. The patient should therefore be informed that the stoma is likely to be permanent and this should be taken into account when considering the type and site of stoma to be formed.