A comparison of the structure of solute clusters formed during thermal ageing and irradiation

Nanometre scale clusters form in Cu-containing reactor pressure vessel (RPV) steels during neutron irradiation. These clusters have a deleterious effect on mechanical properties, which can result in embrittlement and limit the reactor operating life. Thermal ageing of RPV steels can also induce the formation of solute clusters but it is not clear how similar these are to those formed during irradiation. In this work atom probe tomography, combined with detailed structural assessments of the structure of solute clusters, is used to address this issue. A series of thermal ageing heat treatments has been performed on several high- and low-Ni RPV welds to produce 1-4 nm diameter solute clusters. The same materials have also been neutron irradiated. The results show that CuMnNiSi enriched clusters formed during thermal ageing have, on average, higher Cu contents and lower Mn, Ni and Si contents than those found in irradiation-induced clusters. The effect of increasing bulk Ni is to encourage the formation of clusters with significantly higher Ni content, slightly higher Mn and Si contents and significantly lower Cu contents. At very high doses and dose rates MnNiSi enriched clusters can form even in high-Cu welds. Despite differences in the compositions of individual clusters formed during irradiation and during thermal ageing, clusters in both exhibit similar structure. In particular, well developed clusters in both materials have Cu-enriched cores whose peripheries are enriched in Ni, Mn and, in most cases, Si.