Reliability and convergent validity of different BOLD MRI frameworks for data acquisition in experimental arthritis

The clinimetric properties of blood oxygen level‒dependent (BOLD) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for assessment of musculoskeletal changes have been poorly investigated. The study objectives were to assess the interframework reliability of data acquisition of BOLD MRI and to test its convergent validity in chronic arthritis in a rabbit model of inflammatory arthritis as compared with corresponding clinical and laboratory measures.

One of the knees of 12 New Zealand male white rabbits was injected with a 1% carrageenin solution, and the contralateral (control) one was not. Twelve rabbits were euthanized on day 28 of arthritis (chronic arthritis). Clinical (joint diameters), laboratory (serum amyloid A concentration), and BOLD MRI measurements were obtained on days 0, 1, and 28 of arthritis. Twenty paradigms of data acquisition and analysis were applied.

The most reliable MRI parameters set, regardless of threshold values used for data analysis, was spiral technique (level 1), 40 ms of echo time (level 2), 60 seconds of on_ and off_ paradigm (level 3) and carbogen mixture of gases (95% O2 + 5% CO2) (level 4). With regard to construct validity, BOLD imaging correlated moderately (r = -.54, P < .0001) with knee diameters, and weakly (r = -.35, P = .01) with laboratory indices (high threshold for analysis).

BOLD MRI has a substantial or excellent interframework reliability for assessment of arthritic rabbit knees; however, it correlates only moderately or poorly with clinical and laboratory measures. Nevertheless, this study supports further validation of BOLD MRI for assessment of soft tissue changes in a rabbit model of arthritis.