Transcatheter valve in valve implantation for failed mitral and tricuspid bioprosthesis

We report our experience with the transapical transcatheter "Valve in valve" implantation (T-VIV) in patients with a failed mitral or tricuspid bioprosthesis; we briefly review the pertinent literature, and discuss some technical aspects of this procedure.

Redo valve surgery for failure of a mitral or tricuspid bioprosthesis might become extremely challenging, both because of the patients' condition, which is frequently poor, and for the technical aspects of the operation itself, that can be very demanding. T-VIV has been widely employed with good results for the treatment of aortic bioprosthesis failure, and could represent an attractive option in this setting.

Four patients with multiple comorbidities (age: 63-83 years; logistic Euroscore: 37.2-81.5) underwent T-VIV at our institution for failure of a mitral [3] or tricuspid [1] bioprosthesis. A 26 mm Sapien valve was used in all cases. All the mitral procedures were performed via a transapical approach. The tricuspid procedure was performed via a transjugular approach.

The first mitral procedure was complicated by the splaying of the xenograft stents and embolization of the valve. The procedure was converted to conventional surgery, and the patient died on postoperative day 1. In the subsequent procedures, the valve was positioned more atrially, and was fixed to the malfunctioning xenograft sewing ring. All subsequent procedures were successful, all patients were discharged home and were alive and well at follow-up.

The results of T-VIV procedure in the mitral position have been suboptimal, and four of the sixteen patients reported to date died. However, all patients were extremely diseased, and some of the reported failures were related to amendable technical factors relative to the surgical access or to the valve deployment technique. With increasing experience, this procedure might become indicated as an alternative to conventional surgery in selected patients, encouraging increased use of bioprosthesis, and marking a pivotal change in the management of valvular disease.