Utility of 3-year torso computed tomography and head imaging in asymptomatic patients with high-risk melanoma

There is no general consensus regarding the optimal follow-up strategy for patients with melanoma. We sought to determine the utility and cost effectiveness of radiological restaging of patients with stage IIB-IIIC melanoma at the 3-year follow-up time point. A retrospective review of 210 patients diagnosed with stage IIB-IIIC melanoma seen in the Cutaneous Oncology Program at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center between January, 2001 and July, 2006 was conducted. Fifty-two patients were asymptomatic and continuously disease free and underwent restaging head computed tomography (CT) or MRI and torso CT scans 3 years after completion of local-regional therapy or initiation of adjuvant treatment. True positive, false positive and normal scans were identified and the cost per diagnosis calculated. Fifty-five percent of patients developed melanoma recurrences: 88% before 3 years (median time to recurrence 12 months, 95% confidence interval: 10-16 months). The majority of patients (69%) recurred with disease symptoms. Twenty-five head CT scans, 27 head MRIs, and 52 torso CTs were performed. One false-positive head CT and five abnormal torso CT scans (three false positive, two true positive) were identified. The total cost per diagnosis was $312,990. Extensive 3-year restaging imaging seems to be of limited value for symptomatic and continuously disease-free patients with stage IIB-IIIC melanoma. Furthermore, given the low risk of recurrence beyond 3 years, it is likely that subsequent routine imaging would have similarly low utility.