A comparison of inhaled beclomethasone dipropionate and nedocromil sodium as additional therapy in asthma

We have compared the effects of inhaled beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) 400 micrograms day-1 with inhaled nedocromil sodium (NDS) 16 mg day-1 as additional therapy in adults with asthma not fully controlled by regular beta-2-agonist inhalers with, or without, oral theophyllines. Seventeen subjects were entered into a 2-week baseline phase, and subsequently in a double-blind crossover fashion into two 8-week phases of daily BDP or NDS. Subjects recorded daily peak expiratory flow rates, morning and evening (PEF am and pm), symptom scores and beta-2-agonist inhaler use. Thirteen subjects completed the study and the last 2 weeks of each phase were analysed. Compared to baseline, both BDP and NDS caused a significant improvement in PEF am (P less than 0.05), PEF pm (P less than 0.05) and the 'amplitude % mean' (P less than 0.001). Both drugs gave a highly significant improvement in all symptom scores. There was no significant difference between BDP and NDS for PEF am, PEF pm, amplitude % mean, cough and daytime asthma score. However, beta-2-agonist inhaler use and scores for nocturnal asthma and morning tightness were all significantly better in the BDP phase, and may have contributed to its better overall subjective performance. Thus, both NDS and BDP resulted in a significant improvement in asthma control in the subjects studied, and both drugs caused a similar improvement in PEF.